Charlton Athletic 2 Middlesbrough 3
Outcome: Won
Date: 1/10/1957
Manager: Bob Dennison
Attendance: 22613
Competition: FACup ThirdRoundReplay
Played at: The Valley
Goals:
| Goals | Time | Assists | |
| Brian Clough | |||
| Billy Day | |||
| Arthur Fitzsimons | |||
Team
| Player | Yellow | Red | Subbed |
| Bill Harris | |||
| Billy Day | |||
| Brian Clough | |||
| Ronnie Dicks | |||
| Joe Scott | |||
| Arthur Fitzsimons | |||
| Ron Burbeck | |||
| Derek Stonehouse | |||
| Ray Barnard | |||
| Dick Robinson | |||
| Peter Taylor |
Subs
| Player | Yellow | Red | Subbed |