Everton 1 Middlesbrough 1
Outcome: Drawn
Date: 12/4/1909
Manager: John Gunter
Attendance: 10000
Competition: DivisionOne
Played at: Ayresome Park
Goals:
| Goals | Time | Assists | |
| Alfred Common | |||
Team
| Player | Yellow | Red | Subbed |
| John Hall | |||
| Alfred Common | |||
| Steve Bloomer | |||
| Edward Verrill | |||
| Samuel G Cail | |||
| Fred Pentland | |||
| James Thackeray | |||
| Donald McLead | |||
| James Watson | |||
| Samuel Aitken | |||
| Tim Williamson |
Subs
| Player | Yellow | Red | Subbed |